الحديث المتواتر

الثلاثاء 10 فبراير 2009

نص السؤال:

I have a question for you and I hope this finds you, your family and all other beileving Quranists in good health. My question is about at-tawaaturu or al-hadeethul-mutawaatiru. I have concluded that according to Quranic logic (4:11-15) these hadeeth can be considered to be historically sound (as long as they do not contradict the Quran or they are incomprehensible as we are not obligated to follow what we don't understand). However, I still believe that the sunnah/uswah of our prophet is best found in the Quran and anything he did or said outside of the Quran would have been redundant to the Quran. I have had much trouble trying to locate some mutwaatir hadeeth. Do you know where I can find a compilation of mutawaatir hadeeth (with 4+ narrators at each level of the chain) and could you tell me your conclusions about them? I was suprised to learn that this was the mu'tazilite stance, and scholar of old, Al-Jahiz is also a proponent of only accepting mutawaatr hadeeth, and was also a mu'tazilte (I don't like the name but it's the only way to refer to them nowadays). I'm looking forward to your response and again I hope this finds you well.

آحمد صبحي منصور :

According to The Holy Quran , Islam is just Quran and nothing but Quran. My book ( Quran is enough ) is about to be translated into English. It confirms this issue. What is written and attributed to the prophet Mohammed some centuries after his death , is just a human made religion. It is easy to prove it from their own Sunni human made religion. Al Hadeeth Al Motawater itself is our prove here. According to them, there are many different opinions. Some of them said there is no such Hadeeth motatwater at all. Some said there is only one Hadeeth Motawater which says (Whoever says lies and attributing them to me he will be in hell fire), and they also had many different opinions in the text of this one Hadeeth. Some said: there are only three, some said :five, some said nine, but no one of them mentioned those numbers of Hadeeth motawater. Al Kortobi himself confirmed that there is no such hadeeth. All of them said that all the hadeethes in Al Bokhary and others are not Motawater, they are Ahaad. They said also Ahaad Hadeeth is not %100 true, it is just assumption and supposition. The detailsls in my article :
Al Isnad :http://www.ahl-alquran.com/arabic/show_article.php?main_id=20

مقالات متعلقة بالفتوى :

اجمالي القراءات 9805

أضف تعليق

لا بد من تسجيل الدخول اولا قبل التعليق

بطاقة آحمد صبحي منصور

تاريخ الانضمام	:	2006-07-05
مقالات منشورة	:	4245
اجمالي القراءات	:	38,384,262
تعليقات له	:	4,529
تعليقات عليه	:	13,293
بلد الميلاد	:	Egypt
بلد الاقامة	:	United State