ط§ظ„ظƒظپط± ط§ظ„ط¹ظ‚ظٹط¯ظٹ ظˆ ط§ظ„ط³ظ„ظˆظƒظٹ !!!!!!!طںطںطں

ط§ظ„ط³ط¨طھ ظ¢ظ - ط£ط¨ط±ظٹظ„ - ظ¢ظ ظ¢ظ¤ ظ،ظ¢:ظ¢ظ¢ طµط¨ط§طط§ظ‹

ط¹ظ…ط±ظˆ ط§ط³ظ…ط§ط¹ظٹظ„ أ‌أ 2009-04-16

ظƒطھط¨ ط§ظ„ط§ط³طھط§ط° ط§ظ„ط¯ظƒطھظˆط± ط§طظ…ط¯ طµط¨طظٹ ظ…ظ†طµظˆط± ظپظٹ ظ…ظ‚ط¯ظ…ط© ظ…ظ‚ط§ظ„ظ‡ ط¹ظ† ط§ظ„ظƒظپط± ط§ظ„ط³ظ„ظˆظƒظٹ ظˆظ…ظ„ط§ظ…طظ‡ ظپظٹ ظ‚طµط© ظپط±ط¹ظˆظ† :

ظپظ‰ طھط¹ظ„ظٹظ‚ظ‡ ط¹ظ„ظ‰ ظ…ظ‚ط§ظ„ظ†ط§ ( ظ„ط§ ظ†ظپط±ظ‚ ط¨ظٹظ† ط£طط¯ ظ…ظ† ط±ط³ظ„ظ‡ ) ظ‚ط§ظ„ ط§ظ„ظƒط§طھط¨ ط§ظ„ط§ط³ظ„ط§ظ…ظ‰ ط§ظ„ط§ط³طھط§ط° ظپظˆط²ظ‰ ظپط±ط§ط¬ : (طھظ‚ظˆظ„ ط§ظ† ط§ظ„ظƒظپط± ظ†ظˆط¹ط§ظ†, ظƒظ‚ط± ط¹ظ‚ط§ط¦ط¯ظ‰ ظˆظƒظپط± ط³ظ„ظˆظƒظ‰, ظˆطµظ†ظپطھ ظ‡ط¤ظ„ط§ط، ط§ظ„ط°ظٹظ† ظٹظ‚ظˆظ„ظˆظ† ( ظˆط£ط´ظ‡ط¯ ط£ظ† ظ…طظ…ط¯ط§ ط¹ط¨ط¯ظ‡ ظˆط±ط³ظˆظ„ظ‡ ) ط¨ط§ظ„ظƒظپط± ط§ظ„ط¹ظ‚ظٹط¯ظ‰, ظˆط¨ط§ظ„ط·ط¨ط¹ ظ‚ظ„طھ ط§ظ†ظƒ ظ„ط§ طھظƒظپط± ط§طط¯ط§ ظˆظ„ظƒظ† طھظƒظپط±ظ…ط¹طھظ‚ط¯ط§طھ, ظˆظ‡ظˆ ظƒظ„ط§ظ… ط¬ظ…ظٹظ„ , ظˆظ„ظƒظ† ظ‡ظ„ ظ‡ظ†ط§ظƒ ظ…ط¹طھظ‚ط¯ط§طھ ظپظ‰ ظپط±ط§ط؛ ظٹط§ ط¯ظƒطھظˆط± ط£طظ…ط¯, ط£ظ„ظٹط³ ط§ظ„ظ…ط¹طھظ‚ط¯ ظ…ط±طھط¨ط·ط§ ط¨ظ…ظ† ظٹظ…ط§ط±ط³ط©, ظˆط¨ط§ظ„طھط§ظ„ظ‰ ظ„ط§ ظ†ط³طھط·ظٹط¹ ط§ظ† ظ†ظ‚ظˆظ„ ط§ظ†ظ†ط§ ظ†ظƒظپط± ط§ظ„ظ…ط¹طھظ‚ط¯ ظپظ‚ط· ظˆظ„ظƒظ† ط§ظ„ظ…ظ…ط§ط±ط³ ط§ظ„ط°ظ‰ ظ‡ظˆ ط£ظ…ط§ظ…ظ†ط§ ط±ط¬ظ„ ط·ظٹط¨ ظˆط¥ظٹظ† طظ„ط§ظ„, ظˆظ„ظƒظ† ظ…ط§ ظٹظ…ط§ط±ط³ط© ظٹط¹طھط¨ط± ظƒظپط±ط§ ط¹ظ‚ظٹط¯ظ‰, ظ‡ظ„ ظ‡ط°ط§ ظƒظ„ط§ظ… ظˆط§ظ‚ط¹ظ‰

ط§ظ„ظ…ط²ظٹط¯ ظ…ط«ظ„ ظ‡ط°ط§ ط§ظ„ظ…ظ‚ط§ظ„ :

!!

ط§ظ„ظ†ظ‚ط¸ط© ط§ظ„ط«ط§ظ†ظٹط© , ظ‡ظ‰ ظ‡ظ„ ظ‡ظ†ط§ظƒ ظپظ‰ ط§ظ„ظ‚ط±ط¢ظ† ط§ظ„ط°ظ‰ ظ‡ظˆ ط§ظ„ظ…طµط¯ط± ط§ظ„ظˆطظٹط¯ ظ„ظ„طھط´ط±ظٹط¹ ط£ظ‰ ط´ظٹط¦ ط§ظˆ ط£ظ‰ ط£ظٹظ‡ ط§ظˆ ط£ظ‰ ط³ظˆط±ط© طھط´ظٹط± ط§ظ„ظ‰ ط£ظ† ظ‡ظ†ط§ظƒ ظ†ظˆط¹ط§ظ† ظ…ظ† ط§ظ„ظƒظپط±, ط¹ظ‚ط§ط¦ط¯ظ‰ ظˆط³ظ„ظˆظƒظ‰ )

ظˆط¨ط¹ط¯ ظ…ظ‚ط§ظ„ ط·ظˆظٹظ„ ط¹ظ† ظپط±ط¹ظˆظ† .. ط³ط£ظ„طھ ظپظٹ طھط¹ظ„ظٹظ‚ ط¹ظ„ظٹ ط§ظ„ظ…ظ‚ط§ظ„:

ظ…ظ‚ط§ظ„ط© ط±ط§ط¦ط¹ط© ط¹ظ† ظ…ظˆط³ظٹ ظˆظپط±ط¹ظˆظ† ظˆظ„ظƒظ†ظƒ ط§ط³طھط§ط°ظٹ ط§ظ„ظپط§ط¶ظ„ ظ„ظ… طھط¬ظٹط¨ ظپظٹظ‡ط§ ظپظٹ ط±ط£ظٹظٹ ظˆظ‚ط¯ ط£ظƒظˆظ† ظ…ط®ط·ط¦ط§ ط¹ظ† ط£ظٹ ظ…ظ† ط§ط³ط¦ظ„ط© ط§ظ„ط§ط³طھط§ط° ظپظˆط²ظٹ ظپط±ط§ط¬ .. ظˆظ‚ط¯ ظٹظƒظˆظ† ظ„ظ‡ ط±ط£ظٹ ط¢ط®ط± .. ظپظٹ ط§ظ†طھط¸ط§ط±ظ‡ ..

ظˆظƒطھط¨ ط§ظ„ط§ط³طھط§ط° ظپظˆط²ظٹ ظپط±ط§ط¬:

ط£طھظپظ‚ ظ…ط¹ ط¯. ط¹ظ…ط±ظˆ ط¥ط³ظ…ط§ط¹ظٹظ„ ط¹ظ„ظ‰ ط§ظ† ط§ظ„ظ…ظ‚ط§ظ„ط© ظ„ظ… طھطھط¹ط±ط¶ ط§ظˆ طھط¬ظٹط¨ ط¹ظ„ظ‰ ط£ظ‰ ظ…ظ† ط£ط³ط¦ظ„طھظ‰ ط§ظ„طھظ‰ ط³ط£ظ„طھظ‡ط§ ظ…ظ† ظ‚ط¨ظ„ , ظˆط±ط¨ظ…ط§ ط³ظٹظƒظˆظ† ط§ظ„ط±ط¯ ظپظ‰ ط§ظ„ظ…ظ‚ط§ظ„ط© ط§ظ„طھط§ظ„ظٹط© ط¹ظ† ط§ظ„ظƒظپط± ط§ظ„ط¹ظ‚ظٹط¯ظ‰ ظ†ط¸ط±ط§ ظ„ط£ظ† ظ‡ط°ظ‡ ط§ظ„ظ…ط§ظ‚ط§ظ„ط© طھط¹ط±ط¶طھ ظ„ظ…ط§ ط±ط£ظ‡ ط£ط®ظ‰ ط£طظ…ط¯ طµط¨طظ‰ ظ…ظ† ط£ظ†ظ‡ ط§ظ„ظƒظپط± ط§ظ„ط³ظ„ظˆظƒظ‰, ظˆظ„ط°ط§ ظپط³ظˆظپ ط§ظ†طھط¸ط± ظ‚ط¨ظ„ ط£ظ† ط£ط¹ظ„ظ‚ . ظپظƒظ…ط§ ظ‚ظ„طھ ظ…ظ† ظ‚ط¨ظ„ ظ„ظٹط³ ظ‡ظ†ط§ظƒ ظپظ‰ ط§ظ„ظ‚ط±ط£ظ† طھظپط±ظٹظ‚ط§ ط§ظˆ ط¥ط´ط§ط±ط© ط§ظ„ظ‰ ط§ظ† ظ‡ظ†ط§ظƒ ظƒظپط±ط§ ط³ظ„ظˆظƒظٹط§ ظˆظƒظپط±ط§ ط¹ظ‚ط§ط¦ط¯ظٹط§, ظˆظ„ظˆ ظƒط§ظ† ظ‡ظ†ط§ظƒ ظ†ظˆط¹ظٹظ† ظ…ظ†ظ‡ ظ„ظƒط§ظ† ظ‡ظ†ط§ظƒ ط¹ظ‚ط§ط¨ظٹظ† ظ…ط®طھظ„ظپظٹظ† ط¹ظ„ظٹظ‡ظ…ط§ ظƒظ„ ط¹ظ† ط§ظ„ط£ط®ط±, ظˆظ„ط£ط´ط§ط± ط§ظ„ظ‚ط±ط¢ظ† ظ„ط°ظ„ظƒ, ط؛ظٹط± ط£ظ†ظ‰ ظ„ظ† ط£طھط¹ط¬ظ„ ططھظ‰ ط§ط¹ط·ظ‰ طµط¯ظٹظ‚ظ‰ ط£طظ…ط¯ طµط¨طظ‰ ط§ظ„ظپط±طµط© ظƒط§ظ…ظ„ط© ط§ظ† ظٹط£طھظ‰ ط¨ظ…ط§ ظ„ط¯ظٹظ‡ ظ…ظ† ط£ط¯ظ„ط© ط¹ظ„ظ‰ ط°ظ„ظƒ ..

ظˆط±ط؛ظ… ط£ظ† ط§ظ„ط¯ظƒطھظˆط± ط§طظ…ط¯ ظ„ظ… ظٹط¹ظ„ظ‚ ط¹ظ„ظٹ ظ‡ط°ظٹظ† ط§ظ„طھط¹ظ„ظٹظ‚ظٹظ† .. ظˆظ„ظƒظ†ظ‡ ظƒطھط¨ ط¨ط¹ط¯ ط°ظ„ظƒ ظ…ظ‚ط§ظ„ط§طھ ظ…طھط¹ط¯ط¯ط© ط¹ظ† ط§ظ„ظƒظپط± ط¹ظ‚ظٹط¯ظٹ ظˆط³ظ„ظˆظƒظٹ ظƒط§ظ† ط¢ط®ط±ظ‡ط§ ط¹ظ† ط£ظ† ط§ظ„ط¨ط®ظ„ ظƒظپط± ط³ظ„ظˆظƒظٹ .. ظˆط±ط؛ظ… ط£ظ†ظ†ظٹ ط£طھظپظ‚ ظ…ط¹ظ‡ ط£ظ† ط§ظ„ط¨ط®ظ„ ط¹ط§ط¯ط© ظˆط³ظ„ظˆظƒ ظ…ط°ظ…ظˆظ… .. ط¨ظ„ ظˆ ط§ط¹طھط¨ط§ط±ظ‡ ظ„ظٹط³ ظ…ظ† ط§ظ„ط¨ط± .. ظˆظ„ظƒظ†ظ†ظٹ ط§ط¹طھط±ط¶طھ ط¹ظ„ظٹ ظپظƒط±ط© ط§ظ„طھظƒظپظٹط± ظˆ ط·ظ„ط¨طھ ظ…ط±ط© ط£ط®ط±ظٹ ط¯ظ„ظٹظ„ط§ ظ…ظ‚ظ†ط¹ط§ ظ…ظ† ط§ظ„ظ‚ط±ط¢ظ† ط¹ظ„ظٹ طظƒط§ظٹط© طھظ‚ط³ظٹظ… ط§ظ„ظƒظپط± ط§ظ„ظٹ ط¹ظ‚ظٹط¯ظٹ ظˆط³ظ„ظˆظƒظٹ ظˆط·ظ„ط¨طھ ظ…ظ†ظ‡ ظ‚ط±ط§ط،ط© ظ…ظ‚ط§ظ„ ط§ظ„ط¯ظƒطھظˆط± طط³ظ† ط§طظ…ط¯ ط¹ظ…ط± طھط£ظ…ظ„ط§طھ ظپظٹ ط§ظ„ظƒظپط± ظˆ ط§ظ„ط¥ظٹظ…ط§ظ† ط§ظ„طھظٹ ط§ط¹طھط¨ط±ظ‡ط§ ط§ظ„ط¯ظƒطھظˆط± ط§طظ…ط¯ ظ„ط§ طھطµظ„ط ظ„ظ‚ط§ط¹ط© ط§ظ„طھط£طµظٹظ„ ط§ظ„ظ‚ط±ط¢ظ†ظٹ !!!! ظپظ‡ظٹ ظ…طھط¹ط§ط±ط¶ط© طھظ…ط§ظ…ط§ ظ…ط¹ ظƒظ„ ظ…ظ‚ط§ظ„ط§طھظ‡ ط¹ظ† ط§ظ„ظƒظپط± ط§ظ„ط¹ظ‚ظٹط¯ظٹ ظˆط§ظ„ظƒظپط± ط§ظ„ط³ظ„ظˆظƒظٹ ..

ظˆظƒط§ظ† ط±ط¯ظ‡ ط§ظ„طھظ‡ظƒظ…ظٹ ط¹ظ„ظٹ ظپظٹ ظ…ظ‚ط§ظ„طھظ‡ طھط¹ظ‚ظٹط¨ط§ ط¹ظ„ظٹ ط§ط¹طھط±ط§ط¶ظٹ ط¹ظ„ظٹ ط§ط³طھط³ظ‡ط§ظ„ ط§ظ„طھظƒظپظٹط± ط¹ظ‚ظٹط¯ظٹط§ ط§ظˆ ط³ظ„ظˆظƒظٹط§ ظ…ظ† ظ†ظˆط¹ظٹط©:
ظˆظ…ظ† ط§ظ„ظ…ط¶طظƒ ط§ظٹط¶ط§ ط§طھظ‡ط§ظ…ظ†ط§ ط¨ط§ظ„ظ…ط¨ط§ظ„ط؛ط© ظپظ‰ ط§ظ„طھظƒظپظٹط± ظˆطھظƒط±ط§ط± ظƒظ„ظ…ط§طھ ط§ظ„ظƒظپط± . ظ‡ظˆ ظ‚ظˆظ„ ظ…ط¶طظƒ ظ„ط£ظ† ط§ظ„ط¹ظ†ظˆط§ظ† ظ‡ظˆ ط¹ظ† (ط§ظ„ظƒظپط± ط§ظ„ط³ظ„ظˆظƒظ‰ ظˆ ط§ظ„ظƒظپط± ط§ظ„ط¹ظ‚ظٹط¯ظ‰ ) . ظˆظ„ط§ ظٹطµط ط£ظ† ظٹظƒظˆظ† ط§ظ„ط¹ظ†ظˆط§ظ† ط¹ظ† ط§ظ„ظƒظپط± ظˆظ…ظ„ط§ظ…طظ‡ ط«ظ… ط£طھطط¯ط« ط¹ظ† ط§ظ„ط¹ظ„ط§ظ‚ط§طھ ط¨ظٹظ† ظƒظˆط±ظٹط§ ط§ظ„ط´ظ…ط§ظ„ظٹط© ظˆظƒظˆط±ظٹط§ ط§ظ„ط¬ظ†ظˆط¨ظٹط© ظˆط£ط«ط± طھظ„ظƒ ط§ظ„ط¹ظ„ط§ظ‚ط§طھ ظپظ‰ ظ‡ط²ظٹظ…ط© ظپط±ظٹظ‚ ط§ظ„ط²ظ…ط§ظ„ظƒ ط£ظ…ط§ظ… ظپط±ظٹظ‚ ط¨ظ„ط¯ط© ط¨ظ†ظ‰ ط¹ط¨ظٹط¯ ط¨ظ…طط§ظپط¸ط© ط§ظ„ط¯ظ‚ظ‡ظ„ظٹط© !!!!!!

. ظˆظٹظ‚ظˆظ„ :
ظˆظپظ‰ ط§ظ„ظ†ظ‡ط§ظٹط© : ظ†طظ† ظ„ط§ ظ†ط£طھظ‰ ط¨ط´ظ‰ط، ظ…ظ† ط¹ظ†ط¯ظ†ط§ طŒ ظ‡ظˆ ط¢ظٹط§طھ ط§ظ„ظ‚ط±ط¢ظ† ط§ظ„ظƒط±ظٹظ… ظپظ‰ ط§ظ„ظƒظپط± ظˆ ط§ظ„ط´ط±ظƒ طŒ ظˆظ„ظ‚ط¯ ظ‚ط³ظ…ظ†ط§ظ‡ ط§ظ„ظ‰ ظƒظپط± ط¹ظ‚ظٹط¯ظ‰ ظˆظƒظپط± ط³ظ„ظˆظƒظ‰ طŒ.

ظˆظ„ظƒظ†ظ†ظٹ ط£ظ‚ظˆظ„ ظˆط¨ظ†ط§ط، ط¹ظ„ظٹ ظƒظ„ط§ظ…ظƒ ط´ط®طµظٹط§ .. ط£ظ† طھظ‚ط³ظٹظ… ط§ظ„ظƒظپط± ط§ظ„ظٹ ط¹ظ‚ظٹط¯ظٹ ظˆط³ظ„ظˆظƒظٹ ظ‡ظˆ ظ…ظ† ط¹ظ†ط¯ظƒ ظپظ„ظٹط³ ظپظٹ ط§ظ„ظ‚ط±ط¢ظ† ط¹ظ„ظٹ طط¯ ط¹ظ„ظ…ظٹ ظƒظپط± ط¹ظ‚ظٹط¯ظٹ ظˆط³ظ„ظˆظƒظٹ .. ظˆط§ظ„ظ„ظ‡ ظ…ظ† طظ‚ظ‡ ط£ظ† ظٹطھظƒظ„ظ… ط¹ظ† ط§ظ„ظƒظپط± ظˆط§ظ„ط´ط±ظƒ ظˆظ„ظٹط³ ط§طظ…ط¯ طµط¨طظٹ ظ…ظ†طµظˆط± ط£ظˆ ط؛ظٹط±ظ‡ ..

ظˆط£ط¹ظٹط¯ ط£ط³ط¦ظ„ط© ط§ظ„ط§ط³طھط§ط° ظپظˆط²ظٹ ظپط±ط§ط¬ ط§ظ„ط°ظٹ ط£طھظ…ظ†ظٹ ظ…ظ†ظ‡ ط§ظ„ط¥ط¬ط§ط¨ط© .. ظ‡ظ„ ط£ط¬ط§ط¨ ط§ظ„ط¯ظƒطھظˆط± ط§طظ…ط¯ ط¹ظ„ظٹ ط§ط³ط¦ظ„طھظƒ ظ„ط¹ظ„ظ†ظٹ ظ„ظ… ط£ظ„ط§طط¸ ظˆط¥ظ† ظƒط§ظ† ظ‚ط¯ ط£ط¬ط§ط¨ ظپظ‡ظ„ ظƒط§ظ†طھ ط¥ط¬ط§ط¨طھظ‡ ظ…ظ‚ظ†ط¹ط© ظ„ظƒ ..

ظˆط§ظ„ط£ط³ط¦ظ„ط© ط£ظ†ظ‡ظٹ ط¨ظ‡ط§ ظƒط±ظ…ظٹ ظƒظ…ط§ ط¨ط¯ط£طھظ‡:
ظ‡ظ„ ظ‡ظ†ط§ظƒ ظ…ط¹طھظ‚ط¯ط§طھ ظپظ‰ ظپط±ط§ط؛ ظٹط§ ط¯ظƒطھظˆط± ط£طظ…ط¯, ط£ظ„ظٹط³ ط§ظ„ظ…ط¹طھظ‚ط¯ ظ…ط±طھط¨ط·ط§ ط¨ظ…ظ† ظٹظ…ط§ط±ط³ط©, ظˆط¨ط§ظ„طھط§ظ„ظ‰ ظ„ط§ ظ†ط³طھط·ظٹط¹ ط§ظ† ظ†ظ‚ظˆظ„ ط§ظ†ظ†ط§ ظ†ظƒظپط± ط§ظ„ظ…ط¹طھظ‚ط¯ ظپظ‚ط· ظˆظ„ظƒظ† ط§ظ„ظ…ظ…ط§ط±ط³ ط§ظ„ط°ظ‰ ظ‡ظˆ ط£ظ…ط§ظ…ظ†ط§ ط±ط¬ظ„ ط·ظٹط¨ ظˆط¥ظٹظ† طظ„ط§ظ„, ظˆظ„ظƒظ† ظ…ط§ ظٹظ…ط§ط±ط³ط© ظٹط¹طھط¨ط± ظƒظپط±ط§ ط¹ظ‚ظٹط¯ظ‰, ظ‡ظ„ ظ‡ط°ط§ ظƒظ„ط§ظ… ظˆط§ظ‚ط¹ظ‰طں
!!
ط§ظ„ظ†ظ‚ط¸ط© ط§ظ„ط«ط§ظ†ظٹط© , ظ‡ظ‰ ظ‡ظ„ ظ‡ظ†ط§ظƒ ظپظ‰ ط§ظ„ظ‚ط±ط¢ظ† ط§ظ„ط°ظ‰ ظ‡ظˆ ط§ظ„ظ…طµط¯ط± ط§ظ„ظˆطظٹط¯ ظ„ظ„طھط´ط±ظٹط¹ ط£ظ‰ ط´ظٹط¦ ط§ظˆ ط£ظ‰ ط£ظٹظ‡ ط§ظˆ ط£ظ‰ ط³ظˆط±ط© طھط´ظٹط± ط§ظ„ظ‰ ط£ظ† ظ‡ظ†ط§ظƒ ظ†ظˆط¹ط§ظ† ظ…ظ† ط§ظ„ظƒظپط±, ط¹ظ‚ط§ط¦ط¯ظ‰ ظˆط³ظ„ظˆظƒظ‰طں

ط§ط¬ظ…ط§ظ„ظٹ ط§ظ„ظ‚ط±ط§ط،ط§طھ 5577

ظ„ظ„ظ…ط²ظٹط¯ ظٹظ…ظƒظ†ظƒ ظ‚ط±ط§ط،ط© : ط§ط³ط§ط³ظٹط§طھ ط§ظ‡ظ„ ط§ظ„ظ‚ط±ط§ظ†

ط§ظ„طھط¹ظ„ظٹظ‚ط§طھ (4)

1 طھط¹ظ„ظٹظ‚ ط¨ظˆط§ط³ط·ط© ظ…طظ…ظˆط¯ ط¯ظˆظٹظƒط§طھ ظپظٹ ط§ظ„ط®ظ…ظٹط³ ظ،ظ¦ - ط£ط¨ط±ظٹظ„ - ظ¢ظ ظ ظ© ظ،ظ¢:ظ ظ طµط¨ط§طط§ظ‹

[37158]

What i believe

is that Dr. Mansour made that division for sake of comparison and ease of study later. However, i agree he uses it more than should be. Also i admit there is no backup for these division in the Book..

The division has many interesting uses such that it facilitates the understanding of many verses, take these interesting theoretical cases:

1- For example a man that doesnot believe in God but does good to others. This man is kafir in his creed but he is not kafir in his actions! The matter how this man will be accounted in afterlife should be left to God only..

2- A Case opposite to case 1. A man is not good in actions but believes in God ..etc..This man is kafir in behavior but not in creed.Therefore, if he belongs to a Muslim society then the Islamic deterrant laws will apply on him. (for example no intermarriage to that person is allowed..etc)

We cannot make a distinction between the two cases unless we make proper use of that division.

God knows better of course

2 طھط¹ظ„ظٹظ‚ ط¨ظˆط§ط³ط·ط© ظپظˆط²ظ‰ ظپط±ط§ط¬ ظپظٹ ط§ظ„ط¬ظ…ط¹ط© ظ،ظ§ - ط£ط¨ط±ظٹظ„ - ظ¢ظ ظ ظ© ظ،ظ¢:ظ ظ طµط¨ط§طط§ظ‹

[37213]

ط£ط®ظ‰ ط¹ظ…ط±ظˆ, ظ„ط§ ظ„ظٹط³طھ ظ‡ظ†ط§ظƒ ط¥ط¬ط§ط¨ط© ط¨ط¹ط¯

ط£ط®ظ‰ ط¹ظ…ط±ظˆ, ظ„ط£ظ†ظƒ ط¹ط±ط¶طھ ط£ط³ط¦ظ„طھظ‰ ظˆط¬ط²ط، ظ…ظ† ط§ظ„طظˆط§ط± ط§ظ„ط°ظ‰ ط¯ط§ط± طظˆظ„ ظ‡ط°ط§ ط§ظ„ظ…ظˆط¶ظˆط¹ ظ…ظ† ظ‚ط¨ظ„, ظپط¯ط¹ظ†ظ‰ ط£ظ‚ظˆظ„ ط§ظ† ط§ط®ظ‰ ظˆطµط¯ظٹظ‚ظ‰ ط§ظ„طط¨ظٹط¨ ط£طظ…ط¯ طµط¨طظ‰ ظ„ظ… ظٹط¬ظٹط¨ ططھظ‰ ط§ظ„ط£ظ† ط¹ظ† ط£ط³ط¦ظ„طھظ‰ ط§ظ„طھظ‰ ط¹ط±ط¶طھظ‡ط§ ظ„ط§ ط¨ط·ط±ظٹظ‚ ظ…ط¨ط§ط´ط± ط§ظˆ ط؛ظٹط± ظ…ط¨ط§ط´ط± ط±ط؛ظ… ظˆط¶ظˆط ظˆظ…ط¨ط§ط´ط±ط© ط§ظ„ط£ط³ط¦ظ„ط©. ظˆط±ط¨ظ…ط§ ظٹظƒظˆظ† ط°ظ„ظƒ ظ„ط£ظ†ظ‡ ظ‚ط¯ ظ†ط³ظ‰ طھظ…ط§ظ…ط§ ظ…ط§ ط¹ط±ط¶طھظ‡ ط¹ظ„ظٹظ‡ ظ…ظ† ط£ط³ط¦ظ„ط©, ط§ظˆ ط§ظ†ظ‡ ط¥ط¹طھظ‚ط¯ ط£ظ†ظ‡ ط£ط¬ط§ط¨ ط¹ظ†ظ‡ط§, ط§ظˆ ط£ظ†ظ‡ ظ„ظٹط³ ظ„ط¯ظٹظ‡ ط¥ط¬ط§ط¨ط© ظ…ظ‚ظ†ط¹ط© ظ„طھظ„ظƒ ط§ظ„ط£ط³ط¦ظ„ط©. ظ…ظˆط¶ظˆط¹ ط§ظ„ظƒظپط± ط§ظ„ط¹ظ‚ظٹط¯ظ‰ ظˆط§ظ„ظƒظپط± ط§ظ„ط³ظ„ظˆظƒظ‰ ظپظٹظ…ط§ ظٹط¨ط¯ظˆ ط§ظ†ظ‡ ظ…ظ‚طھظ†ط¹ ط¨ظ‡ طھظ…ط§ظ…ط§ ظˆط¨ظ†ظپط³ ط§ظ„ط¯ط±ط¬ط© ط§ظ„طھظ‰ ط£ظ†ط§ ظˆط£ظ†طھ ظˆط±ط¨ظ…ط§ ط§ظ„ط¨ط¹ط¶ ط؛ظٹط± ظ…ظ‚طھظ†ط¹ظٹظ† ط¨ظ‡ط§ طھظ…ط§ظ…ط§, ظˆط¨ط§ظ„ط·ط¨ط¹ ظ…ظ† طظ‚ظ‡ ط§ظ† ظٹظ‚طھظ†ط¹ ط¨ظ…ط§ ظٹط±ظٹط¯ ظƒظ…ط§ ظ…ظ† طظ‚ظƒ ظˆطظ‚ظ‰ ط§ظ† ظ†ظ‚طھظ†ط¹ ط¨ظ…ط§ ظ†ط±ظٹط¯. ط¥ط°ظ† ظپظ…ط§ ظ‡ظˆ ط§ظ„ط®ط·ظˆط© ط§ظ„طھط§ظ„ظٹط©, ظٹط¨ط¯ظˆ ط§ظ† ط§ط®ظ‰ ط§طظ…ط¯ طµط¨طظ‰ ط³ظˆظپ ظٹظˆط§طµظ„ ظƒطھط§ط¨ط© ظ…ظ‚ط§ظ„ط§طھظ‡ ط¹ظ† ط§ظ„ظƒظپط± ط§ظ„ط¹ظ‚ظٹط¯ظ‰ ظˆط§ظ„ظƒظپط± ط§ظ„ط³ظ„ظˆظƒظ‰ ظ„ط¥ظ‚طھظ†ط§ط¹ظ‡ ط¨طµطط© ط§ظ„ظپظƒط±ط©, ظˆظٹط¨ط¯ظˆ ط§ظ† ظ‡ظ†ط§ظƒ ط¨ط§ظ„ط·ط¨ط¹ ظ…ظ† ط§ظ„ط£ط®ظˆط© ظ…ظ† ظ‡ظˆ ظ…ظ‚طھظ†ط¹ ط¨ط°ظ„ظƒ ظ…ط«ظ„ظ‡, ظˆظ…ظ† ط«ظ… , ظپط¥ظ…ط§ ط§ظ† ظ†ظˆط§طµظ„ ظپظ‰ ظƒظ„ ظ…ط±ط© ظٹط¹ط±ط¶ طھظ„ظƒ ط§ظ„ظپظƒط±ط© ط§ظ„ط¥ط¹طھط±ط§ط¶ ظˆطھظ‚ط¯ظٹظ… ظ…ط§ ظ„ط¯ظٹظ†ط§ ظ…ظ† ط£ط³ط¨ط§ط¨ ط¨ط¹ط¯ظ… ط§ظ„ط¥ظ‚طھظ†ط§ط¹ ط¨ظ‡ط§, ظˆط¥ظ…ط§ ط§ظ† ظ†طھط±ظƒظ‡ ظˆط´ط£ظ†ظ‡ ظپظ‰ ط¹ط±ط¶ ظپظƒط±طھظ‡ , ظˆظƒظ…ط§ ظ‚ظ„طھ ظ…ط±ط§ط±ط§ ظ…ظ† ظ‚ط¨ظ„, ط¥ظ† ط§ظ„ط£ط®طھظ„ط§ظپ ظپظ‰ ط§ظ„ط±ط£ظ‰ ظ„ط§ ظٹط¹ظ†ظ‰ ظ…ط·ظ„ظ‚ط§ ط§ظ† ظ‡ظ†ط§ظƒ ظ…ظ† ظ‡ظˆ ط¹ظ„ظ‰ طظ‚ ظˆظ…ظ† ظ‡ظˆ ط¹ظ„ظ‰ ط¨ط§ط·ظ„, ط¨ظ„ ظ‚ط¯ ظٹظƒظˆظ† ظƒظ„ط§ظ‡ظ…ط§ ط¹ظ„ظ‰ طظ‚ ط§ظˆ ظƒظ„ط§ظ‡ظ…ط§ ط¹ظ„ظ‰ ط¨ط§ط·ظ„ ظˆظ„ط§ ظٹط¹ظ„ظ… ط¨ط§ظ„طظ‚ظٹظ‚ط© ط§ظ„ظ…ط·ظ„ظ‚ط© ظپظ‰ ط°ظ„ظƒ ط³ظˆظ‰ ط§ظ„ظ„ظ‡ . ظ…ط¹ طھطظٹط§طھظ‰

3 طھط¹ظ„ظٹظ‚ ط¨ظˆط§ط³ط·ط© ط²ظ‡ظٹط± ط§ظ„ط¬ظˆظ‡ط± ظپظٹ ط§ظ„ط³ط¨طھ ظ،ظ¨ - ط£ط¨ط±ظٹظ„ - ظ¢ظ ظ ظ© ظ،ظ¢:ظ ظ طµط¨ط§طط§ظ‹

[37248]

Can we really know that

Mr.Dweikat

Your questions are fairly logical! but can we really know the answers? I sincerely say that I cannot know them, and I think nobody can know such answers. Is there a general answer for such questions? I myself don't think so, the "Takfeer" thing should be individualized, and it is something only for God to determine, not me, not you, not Mansour, nor the Angels , nobody except God himself

My simple answer to your questions " though not general enough" is the following

question 1: Mostly this man is NOT kafir

question 2: Mostly this man is Kafir if his bad deeds outways his good deeds at the Jugment day

Best Regards

4 طھط¹ظ„ظٹظ‚ ط¨ظˆط§ط³ط·ط© ط²ظ‡ظٹط± ط§ظ„ط¬ظˆظ‡ط± ظپظٹ ط§ظ„ط³ط¨طھ ظ،ظ¨ - ط£ط¨ط±ظٹظ„ - ظ¢ظ ظ ظ© ظ،ظ¢:ظ ظ طµط¨ط§طط§ظ‹

[37281]

ط¨ط§ظ„ط¹ط±ط¨ظٹ

ط£ط³طھط§ط° ط¯ظˆظٹظƒط§طھ

ط£ط³ط¦ظ„طھظƒ ظ…ظ†ط·ظ‚ظٹط© ط§ظ„ظ‰ طط¯ ظƒط¨ظٹط±! ظˆظ„ظƒظ† ظ‡ظ„ ظٹظ…ظƒظ†ظ†ط§ طظ‚ط§ ط£ظ† ظ†ط¹ط±ظپ ط§ظ„ط£ط¬ظˆط¨ط©طں ط¨طµط¯ظ‚ ط£ظ‚ظˆظ„ ط¥ظ†ظ†ظٹ ظ„ط§ ط£ط³طھط·ظٹط¹ ط£ظ† ط£ط¹ط±ظپظ‡ط§ طŒ ظˆط£ط¹طھظ‚ط¯ ط£ظ† ظ„ط§ ط£طط¯ ظٹط³طھط·ظٹط¹ ط£ظ† ظٹط¹ط±ظپ ظ…ط«ظ„ ظ‡ط°ظ‡ ط§ظ„ط¥ط¬ط§ط¨ط§طھ. ظ‡ظ„ ظ‡ظ†ط§ظƒ ط¥ط¬ط§ط¨ط© ط¹ط§ظ…ط© ط¹ظ† ظ‡ط°ظ‡ ط§ظ„ط£ط³ط¦ظ„ط©طں ط£ظ†ط§ ط´ط®طµظٹط§ ظ„ط§ ط§ط¹طھظ‚ط¯ ط°ظ„ظƒ طŒ ظپط¥ظ† "ط§ظ„طھظƒظپظٹط±" ظٹظ†ط¨ط؛ظٹ ط£ظ† ظٹظƒظˆظ† ظ…ط³ط£ظ„ط© ظپط±ط¯ظٹط© طŒ ظˆظ‡ط°ط§ ط´ظٹط، ظ„ظٹط³ ظ„ط£طط¯ ط§ظ„ظˆظ‚ظˆظپ ط¹ظ„ظٹط© ط¥ظ„ط§ ط§ظ„ظ„ظ‡ ظˆطط¯ظ‡ طŒ ظ„ظٹط³ ظ„ظٹ ظˆظ„ط§ ظ„ظƒ طŒ ظˆظ„ط§ ظ…ظ†طµظˆط± ظˆظ„ط§ ط§ظ„ظ…ظ„ط§ط¦ظƒط© ,ظ„ط§ ط£طط¯ ط¥ظ„ط§ ط§ظ„ظ„ظ‡ ظ†ظپط³ظ‡

ظ„ظٹ ط¥ط¬ط§ط¨ط© ط¨ط³ظٹط·ط© ط¹ظ„ظ‰ ط£ط³ط¦ظ„طھظƒ "ظˆظ„ظƒظ† ظ„ظٹط³ ط¨ظ…ط§ ظپظٹظ‡ ط§ظ„ظƒظپط§ظٹط© ط§ظ„ط¹ط§ظ…ط©" ظ…ط§ ظٹظ„ظٹ

ط§ظ„ط³ط¤ط§ظ„ 1 : ظ‡ط°ط§ ط§ظ„ط±ط¬ظ„ ط؛ط§ظ„ط¨ط§ ظ„ظٹط³ ط¨ظƒط§ظپط±

ط§ظ„ط³ط¤ط§ظ„ 2 : ظ‡ط°ط§ ط§ظ„ط±ط¬ظ„ ظ‡ظˆ ظپظٹ ط§ظ„ط؛ط§ظ„ط¨ ظƒط§ظپط± ط§ط°ط§ ط±ط¬ططھ ظƒظپط© ط³ظٹط¦ط¢طھظ‡ ط¹ظ„ظ‰ طط³ظ†ط§طھظ‡ ظٹظˆظ… ط§ظ„ظ‚ظٹط§ظ…ط©.

ظ…ط¹ ط£ط·ظٹط¨ ط§ظ„طھطظٹط§طھ

ط£ط¶ظپ طھط¹ظ„ظٹظ‚

ظ„ط§ ط¨ط¯ ظ…ظ† طھط³ط¬ظٹظ„ ط§ظ„ط¯ط®ظˆظ„ ط§ظˆظ„ط§ ظ‚ط¨ظ„ ط§ظ„طھط¹ظ„ظٹظ‚

ط¨ط·ط§ظ‚ط© ط¹ظ…ط±ظˆ ط§ط³ظ…ط§ط¹ظٹظ„

طھط§ط±ظٹط® ط§ظ„ط§ظ†ط¶ظ…ط§ظ…	:	2006-09-30
ظ…ظ‚ط§ظ„ط§طھ ظ…ظ†ط´ظˆط±ط©	:	131
ط§ط¬ظ…ط§ظ„ظٹ ط§ظ„ظ‚ط±ط§ط،ط§طھ	:	1,408,863
طھط¹ظ„ظٹظ‚ط§طھ ظ„ظ‡	:	1,140
طھط¹ظ„ظٹظ‚ط§طھ ط¹ظ„ظٹظ‡	:	798
ط¨ظ„ط¯ ط§ظ„ظ…ظٹظ„ط§ط¯	:	Egypt
ط¨ظ„ط¯ ط§ظ„ط§ظ‚ط§ظ…ط©	:	Egypt