Search:
From the Archive
Does God The Almighty Forget?!
Allying Oneself to the Weak Ones in Arabia against the KSA
Abraham, the First Muslim
MATIERE A REFLEXION
"Territory of Peace& Territory of War"
Fatwas Part Seventy-Nine
Sharia Legislations and Rituals
The Ferocious Brown Chick Is Threatening Our Person:
Quranic Terminology: Conceal (3)
The real Islamic Jihad in Palestine
Fatwas: Part Twenty-Five
The Destruction of Al-Saud Royal Family Because of Their Repelling Others Away from God's Path (2)
The Exodus of the Israelites from Egypt into the Promised Land
The Metaphysical Realm of Barsakh and the Day of Gathering Which Is the Day of Resurrection
Fatwas: Part Thirty-Three
Clash of Civilizations
An inventory of extremist Islamic texts in federal prisons.
The Timing of the Fasting Month of Ramadan (2): The Lunar Calendar as the Basis of the Islamic Acts of Worship, Including Fasting during Ramadan
Fatwas Part Fifty-Five Issued by: Dr. Ahmed Subhy Mansour, translated by: Ahmed Fathy
Penalty of Apostasy
Latest Fatawas
So do you believe they are true? Or what parts of the Sirah do you tak...
I'm very impressed. I wanted to know how many people follow your point...
Would it be possible if you please could tell me your stand on the "Ta...
Al-Azhar Elevates its' Attacks
Sheikhs of Alazhar: Quranists are Apostates; and the Evidence from the Holey Book Proves Their Guilt
Alshark Alawsat in 07-08-30
Alshark Alawsat

Lately, the Quranists' case occupied the Egyptian public and the religious circles. The Department of Islamic Research at Al-Azhar is currently studying the Fatwa prepared by the Sunna Committee at the department to consider the Quranists to be apostates if they insist to continue refusing the Sunna as a second source of Sharia . On the other hand, The Misdemeanor Court in Cairo decided to arrest what is known as "the Quranists Group" for more fifteen days for investigating the charges of Contempt of Religion, advocating non-stream ideas that cause disturbances in the society.
ALsharq Alawsat asked many Sheikhs of AL-Azhar whether there are proofs from the holy Quran that Sunna is a revelation from God (and since it should be considered as obligatory as the holy Quran)? Alsharq Alawsat asked as well whether these Quranists are really Muslims or not, and whether there are justifications for their call to rely on the wholly Quran alone and ignore the Sunna?
Dr. Mohamed Said Tantawy, the Sheikh of AL-Azhar, replied saying that those who call for relying only on the wholly Quran are ignorant, lairs, and do not know religious rules because the ideas in the Sunna came from God, but it was put into words by the prophet (Peace be upon him). Moreover, Sunna explains and clarify the rules mention as in the wholly Quran.
Dr. Ahmed Eltayeb, the former Moftie (Official Fatwas Issuer), and the current president of AL-Azhar University, commented saying that such calls to separate between the Quran and Sunna are as old as Islam itself, implying that the prophet himself predicted such calls. Finally, Dr. Eltayeb added that without the Sunna, most of this religion would have been lost, and Islam would have been a religion of generalities without an identity.
As for Dr. Abdelhakim ELsayedi, a professor at Al-Azhar University, He relied on the Hadith that says "I came with the Quran and a similar book," to prove that the Sunna is Godly. Not to mention that the holy Quran does not explain how should Muslims pray, pay charity, fast, or perform the pilgrimage.
Dr. Yousef Elbadry, a member of the Higher Assembly of Islamic Affairs, accuses the Quranists of having a strange logic because relying on the wholly Quran only; while the Quran itself -as he claims- is in need for the Sunna,. Dr. ELbadry wonders what the Quranists say about verses like, "He who obeys the messenger obeys God?" Dr. Elbadry added that these Quranists went astray and should be considered apostates.
Dr. Mohamed Abdelmonem Elberry, a professor at the School of Hadith and Explanation, Al-Azhar University, stressed the point that most Muslims have always agreed on validity of the Sunna, whether it is the verbal of practical Sunna. "The wholly Quran ordered us to obey the Messenger, and since this who do not are not true believers," He added.
Dr. Mahmoud Ashour, a member of the Committee of Islamic Research, that the Sunna is indeed a source of the Islamic Sharia, and that those who deny it are illogical because it is impossible to understand Islam with the Sunna. Dr. Ashour stresses that denying the Sunna costs the Quranists to lose their faith. He then called to protect Islam against those Quranists who plan to destroy Islam and pose the greatest threat on Islam and Muslims. He finally accused the Quranists to be spies and agents for other forces to aim at destroying Islam from Inside, but God will protect his religion as he promised.

Read 19127 times

Comments for Sheikhs of Alazhar: Quranists are Apostates; and the Evidence from the Holey Book Proves Their Guilt
Comment By   Mohamed Sadek     - 2007-11-04
Sheikhs of Alazhar:Quranists are Apostates; and the Evidence from the Holey Book Proves Their Guilt
Correction in # 2: "that matter to a human being messenger.

Comment By   Mohamed Sadek     - 2007-11-04
Sheikhs of Alazhar:Quranists are Apostates; and the Evidence from the Holey Book Proves Their Guilt
These comments are just on the surface for now: 1-Do you think if the Sunna came from God, then why the same God did not protect His words as He promised to do so for the Qur’an or may be the same God wants us to get confused and divided in religion? 2-Not every time the word Messenger mention in the qur’an it refers to The Messenger Mohamed (PBUH) or for that matter to a human been messenger. 3-Is in any where in the Qur’an, God give authority to certain people to judge who is apostate or Kafer or something else…?