Search:
From the Archive
Fatwas Part One-Hundred-and-Twenty-One
The Crescent and the Continent
Whom we grant him long life we reverse him in the creation, then they will not use intellect
On Avoiding Hunger Revolts (PART I)
Pieces of Advice Addressed to the Palestinians for the Fifth Time: Say (No) to the Vociferous Devils
Definition of our war of ideas
My Father Is My Problem!
The Rebuilder’s Tale
The Quranic Terminology: Egyptian Prison
Afin de sauver ce qui peut être sauvé: Nous disons ce qui suit à propos de Mohammed Ibn Salman maintenant
Fatwas Part Fifty-Five Issued by: Dr. Ahmed Subhy Mansour, translated by: Ahmed Fathy
The Mecca Crane Collapse and the fall of the Saudi Royal Family
The Persecution of Egypt’s Coptic Christians Continues
Fatwas: Part Thirty-Five
Waking Up The Dead
Safeguarding Houses of Worship
Sociology_of_islam
Abraham, the First Muslim
To the Victims of the Culture of Disgrace and Shame, Who Are Too Much Impressed by the Culture of the West
Prophet Muhammad Was Literate and he Wrote the Quran himself with his Own Hands
Repeating the same mistakes
By: - Amr Jakoush

I thought of sending this article to Secretary Rice but I did not know how to do that. I agree with many of Miss Rice's statement and ideas, but when I look at the application on the ground particularly in the Middle East I discover that the State Department under the leadership of Miss Rice is repeating the same mistakes of the Era of Vietnam and Afghanistan.Secretary Rice said and I totally agree: "...We believe that a democratic, modernizing, moderate Middle East is the best chance for peace in this region, it is the best chance for true stability in this region, and it is the only way -- democratic institutions are the only way that people who have differences resolve those differences peacefully."But my question to her: Is Democracy in the Middle East is different from that in the States or any other Western Country? Is what happening in Iraq is Democracy according to the standards of US and the West? Is Democracy is only about Elections? Isn't it such Democracy that brought Hitler to power in Germany and is bringing in Iraq and Palestine parties that in reality do not believe in Democracy and is completely theocratic? In Vietnam the US backed local Regimes that were not democratic and paid a heavy price for that and then repeated the same mistakes in Afghanistan, It backed radical Islamic movements in its attempt to break down the Soviet Union and paid the price in September 11 and still paying the price in the War against Terrorism.Yes Democracy in the Middle East is the best chance for peace in this region, it is the best chance for true stability in this region, and it is the only way, but Real Democracy, the same kind of Democracy the American Citizen is enjoying.Democracy is a complete pact of principles and not only Elections. I think Miss Rice agrees with me that Democracy means the rule of law, a separation of powers, and protection of liberties of speech, assembly, religion, and property and this is the kind of Democracy we expect the United States and the Secretary of States will back in the Middle East . Democracy and secularism must go hand in hand and parties in Democracy compete according to Political Programs , not because they represent Kurds or Sunni or Shiaats . Such kind of Democracy must lead to the catastrophic situation emerging in Iraq and eventually a more Dictator regime , even worse than that of Saddam will emerge just to implent Security and the States along with Secretary Rice or whoever will replace her will swallow their pride and accept that Regime. In fact Iran and its allies in Iraq and its allies in the Middle East are winning , just because the United States and Bush Adminstration is Repeating the same mistakes of Vietnam and Afghanistan.My last word to Secretary Rice , you are not doing what you previously said about Transformational Diplomacy:" I would define the objective of transformational diplomacy this way: To work with our many partners around the world to build and sustain democratic, well-governed states that will respond to the needs of their people -- and conduct themselves responsibly in the international system…Transformational diplomacy is rooted in partnership, not paternalism""So , Either to be up to your words , and up to the Principles of Democracy and mostly the Principles of the American Constitution or pull back from the Middle East and leave us to our Destiny. At the time being you are doing more harm than good and your last trip to the Middle East is a good proof , tying to make a coalition among regimes that are not Democratic and hated by their people. You only made radical Islamic movements win more grounds and Popularity. I hope I could convey the message as a Middle East Citizen who is dreaming of the Day that Real Democracy will be a fact in the Region, the same Democracy the Western Citizen is enjoying, there is no compromise in that aspect and US should not make any Compromise about what kind of Democratic Governments States thatin democratic, well-governed states that will respond to the needs of their people -- and conduct themselves responsibly in the international system…Transformational diplomacy is rooted in partnership, not paternalism""
So , Either to be up to your words , and up to the Principles of Democracy and mostly the Principles of the American Constitution or pull back from the Middle East and leave us to our Destiny. At the time being you are doing more harm than good and your last trip to the Middle East is a good proof , tying to make a coalition among regimes that are not Democratic and hated by their people. You only made radical Islamic movements win more grounds and Popularity.
I hope I could convey the message as a Middle East Citizen who is dreaming of the Day that Real Democracy will be a fact in the Region, the same Democracy the Western Citizen is enjoying, there is no compromise in that aspect and US should not make any Compromise about what kind of Democratic Governments States that we will be considered partners in this troubled region.
It is the time of real Transformational Diplomacy.

Dr Amr Ismail

The views and opinions of authors whose articles and comments are posted on this site do not necessarily reflect the views of IQC.

Comments ( 2 )
Comment By   Fawzy Farrag     - 2006-10-06
great article
Dear Amr, It is good to see you and read your thoughts once again; welcome to this site, unlike “the other site” you are here among friends. Your article is, as usual, an excellent one, you hit the nail right on the head, however, every thing you mentioned and more, is known to this stupid administration and had been told to them from the get go. The State department has so many analysts whose main job is to collect and analyze all points of view, and report to the decision makers. It is very hard to believe that they have not heard that one before, but they are not super humans, they are people just like you and I, and the fact they could make a mistake and not learn form history, is just another proof of their human fallibility, Politics and the influence of special interest groups, and lobbyists is another factor. No one regardless of their position or responsibly in society likes to end up wrong, but there are many calculations of gain and loss, very similar to a game of chess are involved, and like the vast majority of individuals, who make the wrong decisions in their life, they did the same thing, made the wrong decision. Let’s hope that the next administration will change course, given the fact that they will be running on an opposite platform to this stupid administration. One more thing, it takes two to tangle, the people and governments of the Middle East are as much to blame as the Bush admin. And I, after a lot of thought and analysis, lay the blame on the people NOT the governments, something that I will hopefully be writing about. Regards Fawzy

Comment By   Amr Jakoush     - 2006-10-07
Among Friends , is really what I feel
The great is the comment and not the article. I really feel that I am among friends whom I appreciate and cherish .. I somtimes ask myself what Miss Rice is doing in this administration .. she looks more Democratic. Thanks very much for your comment and I expect the Republican party will loose any presidential election for years to come.